The Case of the Bodnarius: Illustrating how a Rights-Based Framework Separates Children From Parents (Literally)
|Photo of Bodnarius family by Lifenesitenews.com|
When a family is deconstructed by divorce, what should state legislation do to protect the innocent victims of that divorce, the children?
The National Parents Organization published a Shared Parenting Report Card that, for the first time, graded each state’s child custody statutes A through F, and the results were dismal, according to a recent op-ed by Kristen Paasch of the National Parents Organization of Virginia. She writes, “On a 4-point scale, the report found that the nation as a whole scored a 1.63 GPA, meaning most states performed poorly in encouraging shared parenting and parental equality in instances of divorce or separation. This is in direct opposition to current, peer-reviewed research that recently has been published by the American Psychological Association and the Association of Family & Conciliation Courts, among others.”
While this report asserts a focus on what children need, it seems to be most concerned about parental rights in divorce.
The problem is that once a court is invited into the family through judicial intervention in a divorce, the parents’ rights have been essentially diminished from what they were in an intact family, as the family court must now act as parens patriae (Latin for “state as parent”) and create outcomes that are best for the children foremost, as set out at pages 8-10 of the article “Tracing the Foundations of the Best Interest of the Child Standard in American Jurisprudence,” virtually the only legal academic article on the subject. That article argues that the application of this standard has turned toward near pure judicial discretion in contemporary judging causing litigators and advocates to have no rule of law upon which to rely. While setting out the basis for the doctrine, that article calls for a rebuilding of the legal foundations of the best interests of the child standard not only in America and in western tradition, but worldwide, that is not so subjective toward parents and children, but truly works to accomplish what is best for the child, rather than simply what each parent wants.
Parents need to understand that divorce disadvantages the child and the family, and no amount of shared parenting legislation will change that.